PDA

You are viewing a trimmed-down version of the SkyscraperPage.com discussion forum.  For the full version follow the link below.

View Full Version : City (Vancouver) needs commitment on culture, former planning director says



SpongeG
Sep 18, 2007, 5:51 AM
Frances Bula
Vancouver Sun


Monday, September 17, 2007


VANCOUVER -- Abu Dhabi has moved much closer to Vancouver than anyone could have imagined before this year.

It's not just that a raft of high-profile Vancouver planners and architects have been drafted to work at the United Arab Emirates city in recent weeks, including a startlingly high contingent from the city's planning department.

But Vancouver's former planning director, Larry Beasley, has come back bearing the message that Vancouver, for all its successes, has something to learn from this Middle East capital that plans to create a model city by 2030.

This city needs to commit to creating internationally prominent cultural institutions, for one, says Beasley, who gave his first public speech in Vancouver Sunday since he left as the city's planning director last year. He is now a special adviser to the Crown Prince of Abu Dhabi, as well as teaching full-time at the University of B.C.

Abu Dhabi's leaders took the audacious step of petitioning France to have a satellite museum of the Louvre there, Beasley points out. A Frank Gehry design is now in the works. While Abu Dhabi's wealth helps, Beasley acknowledged, it also takes vision and determination to do something like that.

Vancouver's main art gallery, on the other hand, is struggling to find enough money for a new building to replace its too-small space at the former Vancouver courthouse.

"We're not even on the map as far as cultural institutions for a great city," he said in an interview prior to his speech. The city has a great fabric of residential buildings, but it now needs symbolic and architecturally adventurous public buildings to define it.

As well, Vancouver needs to realize that it is not leading the way in the 21st-century push to create green cities, says Beasley. Although it has done well in the past, other cities, like Abu Dhabi, are throwing themselves into that project with much more energy.

"There's a dedication out there to the environment as an urban form-giving principle," says Beasley. "We're still struggling. I used to say Vancouver was at the forefront but I've discovered that this new focus on the environment is happening all over the world."

Abu Dhabi's city plan now includes a 100,000-person development that will be built to be carbon-neutral.

In spite of all this, Beasley points out that Abu Dhabi has chosen Vancouver as the model for its future city for all the other things it is doing right.

Beasley was recruited to be a special adviser a year ago, shortly after Abu Dhabi, one of seven emirates in the United Arab Emirates, allowed private land ownership for the first time and a flock of developers with wildly ambitious projects started showing up.

Beasley, working with Vancouver architect Peter Busby's firm and Joe Hruda's urban-planning group Civitas, has developed a concept plan for the city that will take it from its current population of 600,000 to 3.5 million by 2030. Along the way, the Vancouverites have persuaded the local authorities to abandon a freeway on the verge of being built through the city, created a city concept based on neighbourhoods with a mosque at the centre of each one, expanded on its existing core of stately buildings and tree-lined roads, and envisioned a comprehensive transit system that will primarily benefit the city's thousands of foreign workers.

Beasley said the team adapted Vancouver's established and successful city-planning ideas like focusing on neighbourhoods, de-emphasizing the car, and encouraging density in targeted areas.

"But we did not just import the Vancouver model," he said.

Abu Dhabi, sometimes called the richest country in the world, has vast oil reserves, far more than better-known Dubai, another emirate up the coast that has also hired some Vancouver architects and planners to create Vancouver-like developments.

Beasley said he kept reminding them of the advantage that gave them.

"You are the wealthiest people in the world," he said. "You do not have to despoil your environment."

Nor does it have to make do with second-rate help. The emirate has hired five Vancouver planners from the city recently, including the man heading the city's ambitious EcoDensity project, which has alarmed both staff and politicians here.

But, says Beasley, they won't be the last ones and it has nothing to do with him.

It's not surprising that young people would be attracted by both the salaries -- double and triple what they can make in Vancouver -- and the opportunity to do advanced planning work.

"The attitude in Abu Dhabi is that 'If they're from Vancouver, we want them.'"



fbula@png.canwest.com

http://www.canada.com/vancouversun/news/westcoastnews/story.html?id=ab3ad302-f6dd-4e1e-a262-d15a6baa7da4

raggedy13
Sep 18, 2007, 6:34 AM
Interesting. I wish he would've been a stronger advocate of better architecture/green development/etc when he was behind the wheel.

From what I can tell though, current Vancouver trends and goals have passed Beasley by. There has already been a huge mental shift towards a desire for more interesting architecture, more great cultural city spaces (cultural precinct), and more environmentally conscious development (Ecodensity/SEFC). I'm pretty sure that is one of the reasons they keep fishing for talent in our planning department. Our only major setback is funding which clearly isn't an issue for Abu Dhabi.

I think Brent Toderian has so far done a great job at taking over for Beasley. He's started steering the City in a direction that Beasley hadn't seemed willing to take it. We're slowly but surely getting more architecturally interesting proposals (complete with some more unique amenities and cool lighting schemes), there is a push for more balance in answer to all the residential projects of the last few decades (whitecap stadium, office, cultural precinct), an environmental awareness that is becoming more mainstream in developments, and some great transit/greenway plans (streetcar/Carral Street/Pacific Blvd). It is possible that little of this trend has had to do with Toderian's so far relatively brief stint as head planner but he is clearly an advocate of such things and will only help to keep these trends growing.

paradigm4
Sep 18, 2007, 10:18 AM
I do generally agree that Vancouver is slowly headed in the right direction to fix some of it's current pitfalls, but that's exactly the problem. The city isn't being bold enough. It could certainly go much farther in terms of actually implementing the Four Pillars program and seeing how EcoDensity is dying, Vancouver doesn't have much running for it to be a truly green city. Vancouver isn't even on the map when you talk about the kind of eco initiatives that other places around the world are making. We are just a good model for urban planning mostly, and when I say we, I mean Downtown Vancouver. I don't think Vancouver necessarily lacks culture - I think it lacks internationally viable culture. Maybe that will change after the Olympics. I'd also like to point out that perhaps the reason the City's kind of stagnate right now is because it's focused on preparing and delivering a good Winter Olympics.

jlousa
Sep 18, 2007, 5:39 PM
Those projects we all conceived during Beasley's time, Toderian hasn't had time to change courses yet. I won't turn this into another rant against Toderian, but I'll leave it at, I beleive Beasley was/is underrated and is the superior planner.