PDA

You are viewing a trimmed-down version of the SkyscraperPage.com discussion forum.  For the full version follow the link below.

View Full Version : P-I Article: Site Ranks Walkability of Seattle Neighborhoods



seaskyfan
06-12-2008, 03:10 PM
http://seattlepi.nwsource.com/local/366753_walkscore12.html

Site ranks walkability of Seattle neighborhoods
People are looking to park the car and stretch their legs

By JENNIFER LANGSTON
P-I REPORTER

When Scott Arbeit relocated from Boston, the software architect wanted to live in an urban, walkable neighborhood but wasn't intimately familiar with Seattle.

Not quite sold on downtown, he also had trouble imagining a night life in West Seattle or Phinney Ridge. So he used a Seattle Web site that gives addresses a "Walk Score" based on proximity to grocery stores, restaurants, movie theaters, hardware stores, parks, libraries and other amenities.

That same site now ranks Seattle's 77 most and least walkable neighborhoods -- from Pioneer Square at the top to residential Blue Ridge at the bottom.



When launched last year, the Web site was a novelty -- a fun way to feel smug about a neighborhood's high score or affronted that the site overlooked a favorite breakfast spot. But with growing interest in less car-dependent, more economical lifestyles, its developers are noticing more people using the scores to choose their next home or neighborhood.

"We're actually getting more people (interested in moving). It must be gas prices or more environmental awareness because more people are really saying 'enough is enough,' " said Mike Mathieu, founder of Front Seat, the software company that produced the site.

Rankings depend largely on neighborhood boundaries, and how many residential areas are lumped in with business districts. Compact neighborhoods with abundant businesses -- where people don't have to rely on automobiles to do errands or eat -- are increasingly seen as a way to combat climate change and oil dependence, and reduce obesity risks.

Fifty-two percent of Seattleites live in neighborhoods with a Walk Score of 70 or above -- "very walkable" on the site. Bill Gates' Medina house has a dismal score of 11, while the Fremont Troll is located in a walkers' paradise with a score of 92.

Arbeit found his ideal home after typing in the address of a Ballard townhouse for rent. The computer spat out a perfect Walk Score of 100.

He's no anti-car zealot, relishing cross-country drives, but in everyday life, he's happier ditching the car and walking to grocery stores, movies or to buy a late-night cupcake.

Arbeit discovered Ballard Avenue -- with its historic buildings chock full of taverns, restaurants, wine bars, plant stores, clothing shops, antiques and the Sunday farmers market -- a week after he moved in.

"I busted out laughing as I was walking down the street because this was better than I even knew," said the 38-year-old who works for Microsoft.

But Walk Score has its flaws, since it's built on a Google database that doesn't always reflect up-to-the minute changes; a school listing may turn out to be a storefront business offering karate lessons.

"It's not perfect, but it's better than what we have now, which is no real data and only an intuitive sense of how things are going," said Clark Williams-Derry, research director for Sightline, a sustainability think-tank in Seattle.

And scores also don't reflect other factors: hills, blocks' length, crime rates, public transportation, water bodies or freeways blocking the way.

"This really is a measure of the potential to live a less car-dependent lifestyle," Mathieu said. "It's not meant to reflect whether there are flowers blooming where you're walking. It's more the things that make up everyday life -- are they close enough to you?"

Mathieu, a former Microsoft manager and Internet entrepreneur, has funded the four-person company whose mission is to promote social good through software. In the last year, it produced 14 different ideas -- from Web sites allowing people to buy carbon offsets at gas stations to utility bills that promote conservation by comparing consumers' water and electricity usage.

But Walk Score is the one that caught on. When developers forwarded the link to a few friends last July, it went viral and had 100,000 hits the next day, melting servers.

Now, condo developments such as the Trace Lofts in the Pike/Pine corridor advertise their perfect scores to potential buyers who want to be untethered from automobiles.

"These are people looking for the most up-and-coming type of community," said Jim Goldberg, client services director for the project. "If you drive into our parking garage at any time of day, there are a lot of cars parked there."

Walkable hotspots

Maps on the site show hotspots of walkability in nearly every neighborhood.

Even in Laurelhurst, with a relatively low Walk Score of 56, a low-slung retail strip along Northeast 45th Street ranks as quite walkable.

Erka Gardner, who lives near that strip in UW graduate student housing, was out in a spitting rain this week, pushing a stroller with her 15-month-old daughter aboard encased in a plastic bubble.

It doesn't look like a great walking neighborhood, with seven lanes of traffic whizzing by and FedEx vans blocking the sidewalk while a parking-lot jam clears.

But Gardner walks a couple of miles each day, often buying groceries or visiting U-Village on foot. The area has a great kids' shoe store, she said, and a consignment shop with quilts, used baby clothes, and vintage rocket lunchboxes.

She and her husband wanted a neighborhood where they could walk and commute by bike, but didn't want to be downtown with a baby.

Walkability rankings to guide her search "would have been great," she said. "Especially with gas prices, it's important to us."

The lifestyle clearly isn't for everyone -- with better schools, mountain views or larger homes trumping convenient walking-destinations for some.

To the east, Laurelhurst is a residential neighborhood of immaculately landscaped homes and driveways big enough to play basketball in. It's possible to drive for four miles on tangled streets without seeing a single business.

The priciest areas of Laurelhurst, Windermere and View Ridge rank as almost entirely car dependent, a fact that wouldn't shock anyone who chose to buy there.

The original neighborhood

Pioneer Square, which has the city's highest Walk Score, has the bones for a great walkable neighborhood: two-lane streets, wide sidewalks, tree-lined medians and shops selling everything from high-end furniture to juggling supplies.

"It's the original Seattle neighborhood," said Ryan Romaneski, executive director of the Pioneer Square Community Association. "I think it helps make our case that this community can handle more density without having to rely on single-occupancy vehicles."

Ironically, what the city's most walkable neighborhood doesn't have is a lot of people living there. The city is considering a major rezone of south downtown to allow taller buildings and encourage much denser residential development.

Randy Koch, a storekeeper at Cuttysark Nautical Antiques, said while that could boost business, it could also drive up prices and erode the area's affordability. "Everything seems to be geared towards Microsofties these days -- they are the royalty of the region," he said.

But Williams-Derry argues that tools like Walk Score demonstrate how new urban developments can benefit neighborhoods -- if they incorporate services and businesses that people actually want.

"If you see this is actually going to drive up my Walk Score and make my life more convenient, some of that (opposition) is going to vanish," he said.

seaskyfan
06-12-2008, 03:14 PM
Top 10 Most Walkable Neighborhoods (from the article):

1. Pioneer Square
2. Downtown
3. First Hill
4. Belltown
5. Roosevelt
6. International District
7. South Lake Union
8. U District
9. Lower Queen Anne
10. Wallingford

Biggest surprise to me is that Capitol Hill isn't in the top 10.

mhays
06-12-2008, 03:59 PM
True. With its narrower streets, plentiful supermarkets, restaurants and shops, etc., it should rank high.

At the same time, that's quite an array of walkable areas. We're getting more and more good dense mixed-use districts. In addition to the 10 you can add Capitol Hill, Fremont, Admiral, Green Lake, Phinney, Ballard, Alki, Magnolia Village, Madison Park, Columbia City, Eastlake, Upper Queen Anne, etc.

You can already take a long walk and be amidst density the whole way, like around Lake Union for example. This is becoming true in more and more areas as urban villages fill in and other development happens along arterials like Phinney, California, and Madison. We're nowhere near as dense as I'd prefer, but things are moving in the right direction, and very noticeably.

alexjon
06-14-2008, 06:01 PM
The walk score for cap hill is 100 2 blocks each way around Broadway, but drops instantly to the mid-80s after that

arbeiter
06-26-2008, 05:57 AM
Hey, just who is this wise guy named Scott Arbeit? ;)

I agree with the list except for Capitol Hill not being on there. I don't care what the analysis says, it's simply got among the most foot traffic in the city, it has way more than Belltown.

On a side note, I am moving from Belltown to a weird corner of Beacon Hill that may as well be Rainier Valley.

bgwah
06-27-2008, 04:57 AM
Hey, just who is this wise guy named Scott Arbeit? ;)

I agree with the list except for Capitol Hill not being on there. I don't care what the analysis says, it's simply got among the most foot traffic in the city, it has way more than Belltown.

On a side note, I am moving from Belltown to a weird corner of Beacon Hill that may as well be Rainier Valley.

Decided to stay in awful Seattle?

alexjon
06-27-2008, 03:44 PM
On a side note, I am moving from Belltown to a weird corner of Beacon Hill that may as well be Rainier Valley.

23rd and Morgan area? That hill overlooking Boeing Field

arbeiter
06-30-2008, 04:43 AM
Decided to stay in awful Seattle?

It's still not that great, I'm not staying here primarily for the city. On a day like today, of course you'd think you were in paradise - I was absolutely breathtaken driving around. I rambled around the CD and Madrona and Leschi as well as downtown and Belltown, and it was lovely. But I'm staying for my career, and Seattle's a good place to be for that kind of thing right now.

arbeiter
06-30-2008, 04:53 AM
23rd and Morgan area? That hill overlooking Boeing Field

Nope, although I like that area - my new place is at Massachusetts and 17th Ave S. I wouldn't even call it Beacon Hill, but i believe it technically falls within the city's definition of North Beacon Hill. It is pretty much connected to "High Beacon Hill" by only one road - Sturgus Ave., otherwise the street grid is disconnected from Beacon Hill and is aligned with Rainier Ave. It's a very odd area; it's mostly three kinds of houses - newer 3-story townhomes, older 2-story townhomes from the 50's-70's, and then a lot of foursquares that are either immaculately restored or very worn. The dichotomy of "ethnic Seattle" plays out within just a few blocks - two streets above me and south of me are majority Asian; Sturgus Ave itself and the street I am on is a mix of white, black and Asian (probably majority white though), and then 18th and 19th Ave below me are probably 50% black. That's VERY black for Seattle standards.

It's funny how Rainier Valley is about as nice as any suburb when you look at the surface. It's got very few boarded-up buildings anymore, the new Bartell's and Lowe's and light rail station make it look middle-class as ever. I have not been in the neighborhood overnight or long enough to know how bad it can get though. My roommate tends to pause when I ask him about this - but he's from the area and Seattleites' ideas of unsafe are silly sometimes. I know that the 7 bus can be a bit nutty, and that there were some rapes at Rizal Park, but other than that it seems okay. I definitely, definitely definitely need to get a bike, though. Just walking to the bus stop is 5-7 minutes.

alexjon
06-30-2008, 03:53 PM
Oh god, that area isn't as crime-ridden as people would like you to think. I hope beyond hope that people don't figure that out, though-- it would cause the neighborhoods to fill up and push people out.

Aleks
07-13-2008, 08:55 AM
Seattle Mag just released another list but it's the "Best" Neighborhoods in Seattle. I don't have the list but I know Delridge is number 1 while Broadmoor is number 2.

Broadmoor seems too exclusive to be in the top 5 in my opinion. Visited it a few times. The houses are fatt. So is Howard Schultz' house right next to the golf course. The houses get bigger as you get farther away from the gates.

arbeiter
07-13-2008, 06:42 PM
Seattle Mag just released another list but it's the "Best" Neighborhoods in Seattle. I don't have the list but I know Delridge is number 1 while Broadmoor is number 2.

Broadmoor seems too exclusive to be in the top 5 in my opinion. Visited it a few times. The houses are fatt. So is Howard Schultz' house right next to the golf course. The houses get bigger as you get farther away from the gates.

Sounds like Bellevue wanna be mag. Broadmoor is a private community and therefore should not be on any list. It's the only area of town that voted for Bush, that should tell you something. I grew up right next to it on Aloha, and our house faced downwards into Broadmoor, but we were a world away for we were (gasp) only 2 blocks from Empire Way - aka MLK Boulevard, the road that leads you to the... (psst) central district!



Forums Directory