[Ayreonaut]

If it's only four of us, then size won't matter. Grapevine has the couches at the back, which are always nice. Underbelly would have better beer, and I freaking love the atmosphere there. The Club was mentioned in another thread as being a potential location, though it is a restaurant I guess.

And because none of that narrows anything down whatsoever, I'll go ahead and say that my top choice would be Underbelly. I haven't been there since last spring and have been itching to go back (tried once in October, but during the week and it wasn't open so we stayed upstairs).