Quote:
Originally Posted by the urban politician
Welcome back, Lucien, in all of your Parisian glory!
To be honest, other than the more “classic” version of the proposal across Mary Bartelme park (I hope they don’t go with that one, it will look way out of place in the West Loop), none of these look bad. Even the hotel has the portential to be halfway decent if they at least clad the base in stone and use something decent for the crown
|
Have you learned nothing about Lagrange?
The hotel rendering looks like only the entry portico is stone, and even then it's a dark granite which will look odd next to the precast. As far as the crowns go, I gave up after Ritz-Carlton's crown turned out to be dogshit.
Agreed that the boxy midrise is not offensive. Heck, if built it would be better than the Hayden or most other West Loop condo buildings. At the very least, it's not trying to ape Parisian architecture so it can't utterly fail at aping Parisian architecture. I like how the base is livened up with duplex "townhouse" units that have their own front doors. (that design feature will probably require a variance)
The Mary Bartleme Park highrise is an epic fail no matter which design is chosen. The second one is only slightly less cringeworthy than the first, but what's with those rounded windows? Wendy's called from the 1990s, they want their solariums back...
http://i68.tinypic.com/21270o1.jpg