Originally Posted by SouthSky
This PISSES me off.
Mobile Press-Register Editorial - THIS SHOULD BE ON THE FRONT PAGE INSTEAD OF THAT BRANGELINA B.S.
Senators thumb noses at Mobile, Baldwin
Sunday, May 04, 2008
A COUPLE of powerful senators from northern Alabama need to get better acquainted with the state's coastal region.
Lowell Barron, D-Fyffe, says southwest Alabama is so far away from his district, he doesn't have to consider legislation aimed at helping folks down here.
Rodger Smitherman, a Democrat from way up there in Birmingham, thinks Mobile and Baldwin residents are wealthy "fat cats" who don't deserve any help dealing with the hurricane-ravaged coastal insurance market.
Sen. Barron's provincialism is a problem for coastal Alabama: As the chairman of the Senate Rules Committee, he controls the flow of legislation in that body. The fact he lives some 400 miles from state Sen. Ben Brooks' Mobile district nearly doomed an insurance reform bill sponsored by Sen. Brooks.
During spirited debate over the status of the insurance proposals, Sen. Barron noted the distance between Mobile and Fyffe, and then brusquely advised Sen. Brooks: "I don't have to be for your bill."
Sen. Barron certainly doesn't have to support efforts to bolster the homeowners' insurance market in Mobile and Baldwin. But one would hope naively, perhaps that he would base his position on an assessment of the merits of the legislation, not the location of the sponsor's district.
It's true that it's a long way from Mobile to Fyffe, but an important legislator like Sen. Barron should realize that what happens in Mobile affects Fyffe, and vice versa.
Take tourism, for instance. Tourism is a $9 billion industry in Alabama that generates millions in annual tax revenues for state government. A large percentage of that money comes from Baldwin County, the state's tourism leader, and Mobile County, which ranks fourth in tourism.
The cost of property insurance affects tourism. If rising insurance costs cause tourism along the coast to decline, Fyffe and a lot of other towns in Alabama will feel a bit of the pain.
It's strange that Sen. Smitherman injected class warfare into the debate on the insurance bills.
Angry over Republican opposition to the proposed repeal of the sales tax on food, Sen. Smitherman said he wasn't going to help "all these fat cats" who live in the coastal counties. "We're not going to pass no bill doing all these things and giving breaks for these people that own these $250,000, $500,000 and million-dollar condos," he said.
Sen. Smitherman's ignorance of south Alabama is appalling. The vast majority of people in Mobile and Baldwin are not wealthy. Just about every homeowner in the coastal region rich, poor and middle class has been affected by the rising cost and shrinking availability of insurance.
The fate of legislation shouldn't depend on geography, partisan tit-for-tat or the politics of envy and resentment. Sadly, however, the leaders of the Alabama Senate almost always seem to find the lowest common denominator in any debate.
|