Local developers may get a 10-year lease to spend millions creating Flagstaff Sno Park, a McMillan Mesa sledding facility on 43 acres that would include a "magic carpet" rope pull, lighting, artificial snowmaking, and parking:
A sign warns against sledding and skiing at the site of the proposed sledding facility on
McMillan Mesa Tuesday afternoon in Flagstaff.
(photo: Jake Bacon)
Green light for sledding facility
by JOE FERGUSON
Arizona Daily Sun
May 10, 2012
The proposed sledding facility atop McMillan Mesa that has spent the last few months in limbo at Flagstaff City Hall finally got the green light from the City Council Tuesday. The Flagstaff Sno Park received informal support from five councilmembers for an initial 10-year lease on the 43 acres of city-owned land above Coconino High School. The only dissent was from Vice Mayor Celia Barotz. Councilmember Mark Woodson abstained due to a conflict of interest.
The permanent sledding hill still needs several formal Council approvals, including a lease and a conditional use permit if the latter is appealed from the planning commission. It will include 500 parking spaces, dedicated but separate sledding runs for adults and children, a "magic carpet" rope pull up the hill, a treatment system for making artificial snow with reclaimed wastewater, and lighting.
LIGHTING CRITICISM
The proposed lighting and night sledding drew sharp criticism from several councilmembers. Mayor Sara Presler called the sledding hill "a good idea" but criticized using any lights in a community internationally known for being a Dark Sky city. "I am not interested in night-time activities that create light pollution even if they meet a gold standard," Presler said.
One of the developers behind the proposal, local resident John Crowley, said lighting is an important aspect of the overall proposal but he will re-examine plans to see if it can work without the lights. The lights, he contends, are designed to minimize light pollution and are significantly less bright than the nearby stadium lights at Coconino High School. Crowley said he is also willing to make concessions on the hours of operations if he is allowed to keep the lights, closing at 7 p.m. rather than 9 p.m. He said during the winter months, the park might have to close as early as 5 p.m. without night lighting.
PAST MISTAKE
Councilmember Coral Evans said she supports the Sno Park, adding that the city made a mistake when it closed a small ski run on the mesa 40 years ago. The city operated the facility from 1950 to 1970, when it shut it down over concerns the city could be sued for injuries to skiers. "They should have left that snowplay area open," she said. "I really wish we would have worked that issue out 35 years ago, because we wouldn't be here now."
The sole holdout was Barotz, who told her peers Tuesday night she "struggles" with the current proposal. She did not go into detail about her concerns -- other than traffic -- after conceding she was in the minority. Her only ally might have been Councilmember Al White, who said he would have preferred to see a half-dozen mini-snowplay areas run by the city rather than one large sledding hill atop McMillan Mesa. White was a strong supporter of a failed May 2004 bond question designed to buy a large portion of the mesa for $10 million to keep it from being developed. White ultimately supported the Sno Park proposal Tuesday night.
WEIGHING IN
The Sno Park received verbal support Tuesday night from both the Flagstaff Chamber of Commerce and the Economic Collaborative of Northern Arizona. But Marilyn Weissman with Friends of Flagstaff's Future said her group was opposed, citing concerns about the use of reclaimed water, traffic and turning the sensitive area into major tourist destination. "We would prefer that the city designate snowplay areas, with natural snow when it occurs, throughout town so that kids could enjoy sledding within easy walking distance in their neighborhoods," Weissman said. The Council, not the developers, initiated a request for proposals from private developers to build sledding hills. It allowed for any site to be proposed, including the roughly 40 acres the city owns atop the mesa. The request was designed to divert snowplayers away from the congested Highway 180 corridor.
PAST EFFORT
In May 2004, Flagstaff voters rejected spending $4.1 million in taxpayer money to build a new sledding area with snowmaking, a rope tow and lights. Crowley's proposal is slightly different because it would be funded by a private business rather than the city. City officials confirmed another proposal was informally brought to the city by another developer to build a sledding hill in Country Club near Soliere Avenue. But it was eventually abandoned because the property owner declined to lease the vacant land.
The city has conflicting designations for the 40 acres atop McMillan Mesa -- the current regional plan labels the area as a park while the city's master parks plan suggests the area could be used as a sledding hill. The only councilmember not to weigh in on the proposal was Mark Woodson, whose engineering firm is under contract with the developers to provide drawings and plans for the site. City officials expect the formal lease to be on a Council agenda in June.
OPENING THIS YEAR?
Crowley says he is not sure whether the sledding facility will open this year, adding that he won't place orders for the expensive equipment until he has all the necessary approvals from the City Council. He said some supplies, naming specifically the "Magic Carpet" equipment, would take several weeks before they can be delivered. Crowley has pledged to spend millions to develop the Sno Park. One of the most expensive aspects of the proposed sledding hills, he said, is a water purification system designed to bring the Grade A treated effluent as close as possible to drinking water standards. The city is not requiring that the water be treated to any standard, as it does not have a policy related to the type of water -- reclaimed or potable -- used for snowmaking.
http://azdailysun.com/news/local/gov...0d7f63643.html