Quote:
Originally Posted by Wave
On the flip side, it's a bit disappointing that the Penn Cultural District project will not go full height and is essentially adding a stairwell with two story retail. Good to get rid of a surface lot but that's such a cohesive block and this project would be the sore thumb in terms of height and context.
|
I've been thinking about this more, and while it's a disappointment, and the reasons for not building the full six stories are likely financial, there are solid financial reasons for not doing it.
Basically, look at the facades. It's pretty clear, considering 931 Penn Avenue is built in a virtually identical style to the building which now houses Urban Pathways Charter School, that the missing building was basically a mirror of 931. Anything which doesn't perfectly match the style of the two adjacent buildings is thus going to stick out like a sore thumb, unless it's recessed a bit from the street front or something.
Also, while every building on that side of the block is tall, there are lots of two-story buildings across the street, including the row which includes Sienna Mercato and the single building with the Ben & Jerry's. When it comes to pedestrian experience a continual street wall is the most key thing, because few people besides gawking tourists regularly look up when they are walking around a downtown.
An interesting aside - in back of the building is a private alley which separates it from another little surface lot. This alley, according to property records, is owned by a John Sampson, and is tax delinquent. Apparently "he" has owned the land since 1827! It's hard to believe that this property has had an absentee owner (really no owner) almost since the incorporation of the city.