Quote:
Originally Posted by DoomJ
An article in the Daily News quoted a UTHSC official that the Beale Building site might be a good place for a public-private housing development for students (I agree- but the "might" worries me) but that in the mean time it would be a parking lot (they stated "blight" as a reason for demo... I also consider empty parking lots to be "blight" but whatevs).
|
I agree on that.
Quote:
I don't know... I lament the passing of the Beale Building because its the largest remnant of the Memphis Street Railway Company. As a history geek that burns a little. All that's left now are some polls for catenary wires on Cleveland and Madison, and the occasional streetscape oddity.
I feel like if you want some attractive student housing a converted warehouse would be way cooler than some generic Highland Row-type development, but I guess the generic is better than nothing. Also, the tower part of the building was pretty iconic in that area, at least to me. A lot could have been done with it.
|
I understand what you're saying. One big problem, especially here in Memphis (as we're seeing with the brewery) is that generally no one cares about these older historic buildings until it's almost too late. From a development standpoint, it's usually easier, cheaper, and faster to tear down an old building and plan and build a new one. That's not particularly what I would do, but being involved in both the architecture and historic preservation fields I've seen all too many times developers have big plans for a rehab of an existing building, but in actuality, the support, funding, etc. isn't in place. To complicate that issue, many developers can't afford to wait 5 or 6 years to try to get funding in place, and most of the times it's fairly hard to find a bank or another private financial institution to fund a project.
From an economic stand point (especially for UTHSC), you can tear down the existing building, plan, develop, and construct the new housing or research buildings all while "cleaning up" the neighborhood which most people see as a positive over rehabbing an abandoned or historic property. I somewhat understand that mindset, but at the same time I don't.
Anyways, like you said, it would have been nice to see a rehabilitation and a lot could have been done with it.