Quote:
Originally Posted by manny_santos
While the mayor of any Ontario city does not hold any more power than individual councillors (and up until this year, Board of Control members), the fact remains these massive tax increases occurred under Anne-Marie's leadership. She could have done more to stop tax increases from getting out of control.
|
1) Other than being one vote on board of control (now gone), the mayor has less power.
2) Define "massive", and then define what is acceptable in terms of tax increases - bearing in mind that the inflation rate for Ontario municipalities to operate has been in the 4% to 6% range for years now. In a Joe Fontana'esk way, what would you cut to save tens of millions of budget dollars?
3)What, specifically, could the mayor have done that would have resulted in directly lowering the rate of historic tax increases?
4) Define "out of control"
Quote:
Originally Posted by manny_santos
I should clarify that the $5K figure I'm using includes sewer and water rates, not just property taxes. I sometimes refer to all municipal taxes in general as property taxes, a habit I should break.
|
Water and sewer utility charges are not taxes. They are not even remotely close to being taxes. The City could, if it made people feel better, issue a separate utility bill every month just like natural gas, telecommunications, and electricity (and some municipalities do) instead of invoicing as part of the tax bill - but that would be a wasteful inefficiency.
As a point of reference, water and sewer charges are going up about 10% per year in most Ontario municipalities that have older infrastructure, as a result of the provincial Clean Water Act that was imposed as a result of the Walkerton incident. Both water and sewer utilities must by law be non-profit but financially self-sustaining. Infrastructure must be rehabed or replaced when at the end of its lifespan (and there is a great deal of that in older cities). Operators must be educated, re-trained, certified, and re-certified.
I understand people not being happy with increasing rates for these utilities, but what is really happening is that folks are now starting to actually pay the true cost for sustainable water and sewer services. They never were in the past for a whole range of reasons. lastly, I have to chuckle that folks here are bemoaning the increases in such charges (and yes I pay them too and don't like it), but I also read comments in response to the most recent annual spills report about sewage treatment plants having to divert overflows into the Thames, and the infamous watermain break at Dundas and Wellington several years back being the fault of A.M. D.-B. and her "ilk".
Can't have it both ways boys.
Oh, and BTW, just wait 'till the STORM SEWER utility really ramps up as federal and provincial environmental regs ramp up in the future.