from the Sunday Oregonian
In Milwaukie's city center project, there's no Dark Horse candidate
Sunday, April 01, 2007
RANDY GRAGG
Imagine a business more than 100 employees strong, filling six downtown buildings and ready to take on more. It makes books, films and products with an international audience. The staff is the "creative class" every town in America is aching for.
Now imagine the city where this business lives wants to build a new "town center" with retail and condos -- and some expansion space -- across the street from a planned new waterfront park.
Sound like a dream project for an enterprising developer?
You sure wouldn't know it from the proposals three developer/architect teams submitted for Milwaukie's Town Center Project.
One would add to Milwaukie's eclectic collection of architecture. One is unbuildable. One is simply generic.
None of the developers even attempted to incorporate downtown Milwaukie's greatest creative and economic force -- Dark Horse Comics, the $30 million-a-year producer of such legendary cartoon and movie titles as "The Mask" and "Sin City."
Too bad. The Town Center project has all the markings of being the proverbial "tipping point" in downtown Milwaukie's revival. This is a place 10 minutes from downtown Portland by car (or just 30 minutes by bike on the beautiful Springwater Trail). A light rail connection to Portland, though still distant, is almost certainly on the way.
The city of Milwaukie and Metro Regional Government joined hands to buy an old Texaco station next to City Hall and across the street from the waterfront park. Metro sees this as a marquee project in its ongoing "Centers" effort to seed higher-density mixes of housing and retail in the region's existing downtowns. For the winning developer, the land likely will be substantially discounted.
There's still no shortage of risk. The site may overlook the river, but it sits right on Southeast McLoughlin Boulevard, aka Oregon 99E. Downtown Milwaukie's commercial rents are about 75 percent of what will be necessary to pay for new office construction. Condo prices are still so low that anything beyond wood-frame construction is a stretch.
Yet, by the time this building opens, the new park could easily be under construction and the coming of light rail confirmed.
A leap of faith could be grandly rewarded.
The three proposals could not be more distinct, both architecturally and in how they seem to see downtown Milwaukie's future.
Costa Pacific Homes, known for its work at Orenco Station and Villebois, went to Boise for its architect -- Mark Sanders of The Architects Office -- who, in turn, freely concedes his best ideas come from Portland's Pearl District. It shows. Costa's Pearlish, five-story, 71-condo scheme is a brick dream that, from its corner turret to its five stories sitting atop underground parking, is an almost-certain financial impossibility.
At the other end of the spectrum is Winkler Development Co.'s scheme, which offers its 63 condo owners a river view over an eco-roof. But for this downtown gateway site, it would face McLoughlin and the future park with a parking garage.
Falling between those two mostly brick schemes is the team of KemperCo and Myhre Group Architects, which are proposing a wood- and metal panel-clad building with 76 condos. It's by far the smartest urban design and, last week, got the initial nod from the Town Center's project management group. With the parking tucked in the middle, it faces McLoughlin with small offices and downtown with future stores and restaurants.
At a recent open house, many Milwaukians argued the Myhre Group's architecture won't fit in. But from its jaunty Venetian-style Masonic Lodge to its sharply soaring Modernist St. John the Baptist Catholic Church to the blinking lights of its Wunderland arcade, Milwaukie is a crazy quilt that only grows richer with each bold new patch.
Yet the absence of space for Dark Horse Comics is sad -- for Dark Horse, the city and this project.
Neil Hankerson, Dark Horse's executive vice president, says the company is close to capacity in its existing space. He and founder Mike Richardson are tired of having critical creative functions split between buildings. They dream of 25,000 square feet of contiguous space.
"You miss the water cooler conversations," Hankerson says. "It's easier to keep the sense of being a family."
With construction prices soaring, building the type of space Dark Horse could rent or buy is a tough deal, for sure. Metro, Milwaukie and the developer would need to stretch to make it work. But given how hard cities elsewhere in the world are working to lure companies like Dark Horse, it sure seems like a good idea to work a little harder to help a home-grown one grow some more.
Calling Gov. Kulongoski: If ever there was an opportunity to tell the world what Oregon economic development is about, it's here.
Randy Gragg: 503-221-8575;
randygragg@news.oregonian.com
http://www.oregonlive.com/oregonian/...430.xml&coll=7
there were pictures of all three proposals in the paper too, but i got no scanner, so sorry on that front.