Quote:
Originally Posted by Westsidelife
That makes sense. What about the building with the black windows below the smaller tower? Is that an existing building or part of the project? As for the left 'midsection' I'd prefer it to be touching the ground but it'd be cool if it was above street level.
|
The building with the black "windows" is part of the project. That corner is currently a parking lot. If you look at the colored massing model, it appears that the building with the horizontal black "windows" is a parking garage, the orange areas are the live/work "pods" (which appear to be two stories, like the live/work spaces on the ground floor of Elleven), and the blue areas are the condos.
What I don't like about the design of the tower is how they repeat that cutaway and triple "eyebrow" motif on every corner, alternating it on different sides as it goes up. If that motif was there once, or perhaps twice, it would be a nice way to break up a tall, sleek, slender tower. But when they repeat it like this, it just looks messy, busy and tacky - in a sort of bad-dream-from-1980's-Miami way. The result is a tower that's as sleek as cheese grater and as refined as a Hooter's T-shirt.
Also, the urban planning of this is a nightmare. It appears that they've put a giant "hole" at street level along fifth street that leads into a courtyard, which looks up to a parking garage. That's wasting the best stretch of ground floor retail potential - along 5th Street facing Pershing Square. What, do they plan to put retail along Olive Street? So you can walk up a steep hill? Or better yet, inside the courtyard??
If they wanted to do this right, they would close up that ridiculous hole and put retail along 5th street, and extend a 2-3 story podium behind the retail throughout the entire site that would contain parking inside and a landscaped courtyard with pool in the center. That way residents of this development would have killer views of the Subway Terminal building (Metro417) - especially at night - and Forrest City could charge an arm and a leg to hundreds of voyeurs who would be tripping over themselves to get "pool view" apartments. It would also create a lot more parking spaces that could be used for events like Grand Performances or ice skating at Pershing Square. My guess is that they can't go underground for parking on the east side of this site with the subway being right there.
They really need to go back to the drawing board on this one, IMO.