Quote:
Originally Posted by lio45
I went to see my mystery tree today, here are pics of the leaves and bark. I found another younger tree of the same species nearby, took pics of that one too as it shows less mature bark (one more clue).
It does look like elm to me... however no idea if red ("Slippery") or white ("American").
The base of the leaves don't really have that asymmetry that Northern Light highlighted, but if it's not an elm I really don't see what else it can be.
IMG_1124
IMG_1125
IMG_1126
IMG_1127
|
So............
I didn't forget about you.
There were some competing indicators............so I sent your photos to a professional forester friend for a second opinion.
We compared notes and we are reasonably confident that its Red Elm.
The peeling of the bark on the mature specimen near the bottom is inconsistent with Ironwood.
Its also tough to tell, but the tree appears a bit too tall for Ironwood, which we agreed caps out at about 40ft.
The leaves are resprouts and those on any tree often show substantial variation from the typical leaf of a given tree.
But by way of deciding the bark precludes Ironwood, we assume the leaf must be Elm.
To differentiate Red from White elm is tough and more about the buds than anything.
That said, the Red Elm leaf tends to be a bit narrower and the teeth a bit finer than on White Elm. Not a hard/fast rule.........
But on the basis, Red Elm seems most likely.
Also, unfortunately, the peeling of the lower bark and the extensive resprouting may be indicative of Dutch Elm.
It certainly suggests the tree is stressed at the canopy level.
The stress could have other causes.
If it does have DED its worth saying its often not fatal, some trees power through.