Quote:
Originally Posted by dropdeaded209
this one's a miss for me--i was hoping the lantern would help even out the proportions and the massing but i dunno it just feels awkward--still gotta wait until the crane is down and it's all wrapped up but IMHO it definitely lacks the romance of the Jahn towers or even the brooding authority of RAMSA's Comcast building.
am i alone in this?
|
I used to have this very same opinion when this building first started going up but had a feeling it would turn out better than the renderings. I thought the massing was awkward but now I see it as bold and unique! This tower really fits in with the rest of the skyline and looks like it's been there for years. I never felt that the original Comcast Tower had the same prominence One Liberty used to have on the skyline and I think this tower matches it, a fitting tower to hold the distinction of Philly's tallest.
My only complaint is that it does block a huge portion of the skyline when viewed from the northwest. But as seen in TallCoolOne's pictures, it makes up for it by looking absolutely iconic when viewed from that angle.