HomeDiagramsDatabaseMapsForum
     

Go Back   SkyscraperPage Forum > Discussion Forums > City Discussions

Reply

 
Thread Tools Display Modes
     
     
  #201  
Old Posted Jun 18, 2019, 11:17 AM
Crawford Crawford is online now
Registered User
 
Join Date: Nov 2003
Location: Brooklyn, NYC/Polanco, DF
Posts: 18,156
Quote:
Originally Posted by _C2_ View Post
NYC and LA are near equals these days. And if Manhattan (and the Bronx) deannexed that major city and county with its own villages and towns (like Flushing and LI City) on Long Island, New York suddenly wouldn't be any bigger than LA.
If NYC "deannexed" to a village of 12, it wouldn't change a thing. It would have the exact same MSA, CSA, and UA populations.

And LIC and Flushing haven't been separate "villages and towns" for 150 years. What does that even mean? Everything outside the original Dutch settlement was at one time a separate "village".
Reply With Quote
     
     
  #202  
Old Posted Jun 18, 2019, 1:25 PM
SpawnOfVulcan's Avatar
SpawnOfVulcan SpawnOfVulcan is offline
Cat Enthusiast
 
Join Date: Apr 2008
Location: America's Magic City
Posts: 3,545
Quote:
Originally Posted by Acajack View Post
I have doubts about Rome and Rio being number twos. It could be argued they are co-number-1s. Aside from population bean-counting.

At least no one I know would call them also-rans.
I agree. While Piemonte is the economic powerhouse of Italy, Rome is still the most culturally significant city in the country. I think Milan is a solid second city for Italy.
__________________
SSP Alabama Metros: Birmingham (City Compilation) - Huntsville - Mobile - Montgomery - Tuscaloosa - Daphne-Fairhope - Decatur

SSP Alabama Universities: Alabama - UAB - Alabama State
Reply With Quote
     
     
  #203  
Old Posted Jun 18, 2019, 1:54 PM
Acajack's Avatar
Acajack Acajack is online now
Jos Connaissant
 
Join Date: Aug 2006
Location: Vieux Canada
Posts: 39,129
Quote:
Originally Posted by SpawnOfVulcan View Post
I agree. While Piemonte is the economic powerhouse of Italy, Rome is still the most culturally significant city in the country. I think Milan is a solid second city for Italy.
Politically too.
__________________
The pendulum is swinging back. Everybody duck!
Reply With Quote
     
     
  #204  
Old Posted Jun 18, 2019, 6:44 PM
ThePhun1 ThePhun1 is offline
Registered User
 
Join Date: Sep 2014
Location: Houston/Galveston
Posts: 1,649
Quote:
Originally Posted by Crawford View Post
If NYC "deannexed" to a village of 12, it wouldn't change a thing. It would have the exact same MSA, CSA, and UA populations.

And LIC and Flushing haven't been separate "villages and towns" for 150 years. What does that even mean? Everything outside the original Dutch settlement was at one time a separate "village".
What it means is that NYC took over a city in its own right (Brooklyn) and a county (Queens) as well as for some odd reason an island that might as well be in New Jersey. Take that away and NYC and LA are similar sizes (take the San Fernando Valley away if you wanna argue that next). There's not the gap between the two as there is with Rio and SP.

And yes, I know NYC's MSA is bigger.
Reply With Quote
     
     
  #205  
Old Posted Jun 18, 2019, 6:54 PM
iheartthed iheartthed is offline
Registered User
 
Join Date: Oct 2009
Location: New York
Posts: 2,205
Quote:
Originally Posted by ThePhun1 View Post
What it means is that NYC took over a city in its own right (Brooklyn) and a county (Queens) as well as for some odd reason an island that might as well be in New Jersey. Take that away and NYC and LA are similar sizes (take the San Fernando Valley away if you wanna argue that next). There's not the gap between the two as there is with Rio and SP.

And yes, I know NYC's MSA is bigger.
And Los Angeles never annexed anything, ever.
Reply With Quote
     
     
  #206  
Old Posted Jun 18, 2019, 6:54 PM
Obadno Obadno is offline
Registered User
 
Join Date: Jan 2010
Posts: 2,977
Quote:
Originally Posted by liat91 View Post
For the US I will use regions.
NE: DC
South: Atlanta
Midwest: Detroit
West: San Francisco

Germany: Hamburg
France: Lyon
Italy: Rome
UK: Manchester
Australia: Melbourne
Japan: Osaka
China: Beijing
Mexico: Guadalajara
Brazil: Rio
India: Delhi
I was about to call you crazy and then I realized you ere talking "seconds"

The only one disputable would be Detroit. What about Minni? STL? Cleaveland? I feel like there are better Choices now over Detroit.
Reply With Quote
     
     
  #207  
Old Posted Jun 18, 2019, 6:57 PM
Steely Dan's Avatar
Steely Dan Steely Dan is online now
devout Pizzatarian
 
Join Date: Jul 2001
Location: Lincoln Square, Chicago
Posts: 20,730
Quote:
Originally Posted by Obadno View Post
The only one disputable would be Detroit. What about Minni? STL? Cleaveland? I feel like there are better Choices now over Detroit.
in the context of the thread, many people are using "2nd city" as the 2nd largest, or 2nd most important (as measured by GDP) city.

by the measures of size and economy, detroit is the midwest's 2nd city. but the twin cities are creeping up on the motor city, and growing faster.

st. louis and cleveland wouldn't really be in the running for #2 in the midwest.


2018 MSA population

detroit: 4,326,442
twin cities: 3,629,190
st. louis: 2,805,465
cleveland: 2,057,009





2010-2018 MSA pop. growth

detroit: +0.70%
twin cities: +8.37%
st. louis: +0.64%
cleveland: −0.97%





2017 MSA GDP

detroit: $260.612 Billion
twin cities: $260.106 Billion
st. louis: $161.281 Billion
cleveland: $138.980 Billion
__________________
He has to go.

Last edited by Steely Dan; Jun 18, 2019 at 7:18 PM.
Reply With Quote
     
     
  #208  
Old Posted Jun 18, 2019, 6:57 PM
Crawford Crawford is online now
Registered User
 
Join Date: Nov 2003
Location: Brooklyn, NYC/Polanco, DF
Posts: 18,156
Quote:
Originally Posted by ThePhun1 View Post
What it means is that NYC took over a city in its own right (Brooklyn) and a county (Queens) as well as for some odd reason an island that might as well be in New Jersey.
I don't understand the point. City size (or population) have nothing to do with relative metro size.

Are you aware of any major city in existence that is the exact same size as at its founding? NYC is actually odd in that there have been no territorial expansions since the 19th century. Only a few big U.S. cities have had such longstanding fixed limits.

LA had massive 20th century expansions, up until WW2. That's really a more typical U.S. scenario.
Reply With Quote
     
     
  #209  
Old Posted Jun 18, 2019, 7:03 PM
iheartthed iheartthed is offline
Registered User
 
Join Date: Oct 2009
Location: New York
Posts: 2,205
Quote:
Originally Posted by Crawford View Post
I don't understand the point. City size (or population) have nothing to do with relative metro size.

Are you aware of any major city in existence that is the exact same size as at its founding? NYC is actually odd in that there have been no territorial expansions since the 19th century. Only a few big U.S. cities have had such longstanding fixed limits.

LA had massive 20th century expansions, up until WW2. That's really a more typical U.S. scenario.
The point was silly and almost not worth responding to... But since we are, it's also worth pointing out that Los Angeles has a significantly larger land area than NYC. If NYC extended its borders into New Jersey to match LA's land area, the city would easily be over 10M in population.
Reply With Quote
     
     
  #210  
Old Posted Jun 18, 2019, 7:27 PM
mrnyc mrnyc is offline
Registered User
 
Join Date: Jul 2006
Posts: 5,411
for ohioans, there is no second city. well of course technically there is, but not in the state mindset. most ohioans think of it as there are the three C's, cleveland, columbus and cincinnati, in no order really, and then there are three red-headed step sister cities so to speak, toledo, akron and dayton. and even after that there is quite a broad mix of suburbs, small cities and towns and country villages and the like. so ohio state is really most notable for its variety and not for having one big city and one second tier city, maybe kind of like california and texas i would say.
Reply With Quote
     
     
  #211  
Old Posted Jun 18, 2019, 9:20 PM
Steely Dan's Avatar
Steely Dan Steely Dan is online now
devout Pizzatarian
 
Join Date: Jul 2001
Location: Lincoln Square, Chicago
Posts: 20,730
Quote:
Originally Posted by mrnyc View Post
so ohio state is really most notable for its variety and not for having one big city and one second tier city, maybe kind of like california and texas i would say.
ohio is like the anti-illinois.

neither state has a clear-cut "2nd city", but for very different reasons.

both states have similar overall populations/sizes, however, in illinois 75% of the people are crammed into one single super-metro in the far NE corner of the state, with nothing but small cities/towns and cornfields spread across the rest of the state, while in ohio the population is MUCH more widely distributed across a vast array of small, medium, and large cities that span from one end of the state to the other.
__________________
He has to go.
Reply With Quote
     
     
  #212  
Old Posted Jun 18, 2019, 10:06 PM
subterranean's Avatar
subterranean subterranean is offline
homesick alien
 
Join Date: Oct 2003
Location: Portland
Posts: 2,681
Quote:
Originally Posted by mrnyc View Post
most ohioans think of it as there are the three C's, cleveland, columbus and cincinnati, in no order really, and then there are three red-headed step sister cities so to speak, toledo, akron and dayton.
Toledo is Michigan's second city, silly.
__________________
SW Portland | NW Portland
Reply With Quote
     
     
  #213  
Old Posted Jun 19, 2019, 2:51 PM
Centropolis's Avatar
Centropolis Centropolis is offline
crisis actor
 
Join Date: Nov 2009
Location: under the coin of caesar
Posts: 9,551
Quote:
Originally Posted by Steely Dan View Post
st. louis and cleveland wouldn't really be in the running for #2 in the midwest.
*bass-y/garbled pre-recorded auditorium/voice actor voice*

As the ancient capital of the Mississippian Civilization , and later settled in the late 1600s by Canadien explorers, the St. Louis region is home to the primate metropolis of the lands stretching from the Appalachian uplift to the slopes of the Rocky Mountains. Poised to reach 17 million by 1997, St. Louis has....

*pipe noise*
__________________
t h e r e is no C h a o s.... . . . only g r e a t E n e r g y
Reply With Quote
     
     
  #214  
Old Posted Jun 19, 2019, 3:23 PM
Buckeye Native 001 Buckeye Native 001 is offline
is a loser.
 
Join Date: Aug 2003
Location: Arizona
Posts: 29,458
Who really won the Toledo War?

Hint: It wasn't Ohio.
Reply With Quote
     
     
  #215  
Old Posted Jun 19, 2019, 4:48 PM
iheartthed iheartthed is offline
Registered User
 
Join Date: Oct 2009
Location: New York
Posts: 2,205
Quote:
Originally Posted by Buckeye Native 001 View Post
Who really won the Toledo War?

Hint: It wasn't Ohio.
Hindsight is 20/20.
Reply With Quote
     
     
  #216  
Old Posted Jun 20, 2019, 3:52 AM
Angalfaria Angalfaria is offline
Registered User
 
Join Date: May 2019
Location: Dubai
Posts: 24
Excellent read, I love the second and third cities. There were a lot of cities in the UAE and people must visit there.
Thanks for a beautiful input about the second cities.
Reply With Quote
     
     
  #217  
Old Posted Jun 20, 2019, 9:16 AM
Doug's Avatar
Doug Doug is offline
Registered User
 
Join Date: Jul 2001
Posts: 9,402
Quote:
Originally Posted by Steely Dan View Post
^ and if you go back to australia's earliest colonial days, sydney was where the first permanent european settlement (prison colony) was set up on the australian continent, and was thus australia's very first city.

so sydney and melbourne have been flip-flopping for some time.
Melbourne passed Sydney in both population and economy not long after its founding due to the Victorian Gold Rush of the 1850’s through 70’s.

Today, the two cities are evenly matched economically. For example, of the ten largest Australian corporations by revenue:

Wesfarmers ($69 billion) - Perth
Woolworths ($56 billion) - Sydney
Commonwealth Bank of Australia ($45 billion) - Sydney
BHP ($39 billion) - Melbourne
Westpac Banking Corporation ($38 billion) - Sydney
Rio Tinto ($35 billion) - Melbourne
ANZ Banking Group ($34 billion) - Melbourne
NAB ($32 billion) - Melbourne
Telstra ($28 billion) - Melbourne
NSW Health ($21 billion) - Sydney
Reply With Quote
     
     
  #218  
Old Posted Jun 22, 2019, 11:41 AM
Razor Razor is offline
Registered User
 
Join Date: Jul 2011
Location: Ottawa
Posts: 2,046
Quote:
Originally Posted by mrnyc View Post
for ohioans, there is no second city. well of course technically there is, but not in the state mindset. most ohioans think of it as there are the three C's, cleveland, columbus and cincinnati, in no order really, and then there are three red-headed step sister cities so to speak, toledo, akron and dayton. and even after that there is quite a broad mix of suburbs, small cities and towns and country villages and the like. so ohio state is really most notable for its variety and not for having one big city and one second tier city, maybe kind of like california and texas i would say.
I always found that interesting about Ohio. What if in alternate history, one of the "C's" became a 5m+ mega city at the expense of the other two remaing the size of Toledo or Dayton? Our province of Ontario is cut up a little differently.It has 14m residents, but doesn't have any metros as large as any of the C's. It has one juggernaut, 1 metro over a million, 1 just under, and a handful of Toledo sized metros.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Steely Dan View Post
in the context of the thread, many people are using "2nd city" as the 2nd largest, or 2nd most important (as measured by GDP) city.

by the measures of size and economy, detroit is the midwest's 2nd city. but the twin cities are creeping up on the motor city, and growing faster.
From somebody from another Country's POV, Detroit is definitely your Midwest's 2nd city..It just has that legacy status. Being the centre of the car industry plus having that iconic Motown recording scene from decades past attributes to that.

Last edited by Razor; Jun 22, 2019 at 12:26 PM.
Reply With Quote
     
     
  #219  
Old Posted Jun 22, 2019, 2:11 PM
subterranean's Avatar
subterranean subterranean is offline
homesick alien
 
Join Date: Oct 2003
Location: Portland
Posts: 2,681
Quote:
Originally Posted by Razor View Post
I always found that interesting about Ohio. What if in alternate history, one of the "C's" became a 5m+ mega city at the expense of the other two remaing the size of Toledo or Dayton? Our province of Ontario is cut up a little differently.It has 14m residents, but doesn't have any metros as large as any of the C's. It has one juggernaut, 1 metro over a million, 1 just under, and a handful of Toledo sized metros.

From somebody from another Country's POV, Detroit is definitely your Midwest's 2nd city..It just has that legacy status. Being the centre of the car industry plus having that iconic Motown recording scene from decades past attributes to that.
You’re basically describing Ohio’s neighbor to the north. Lower Michigan has one “juggernaut” over 5 million (Detroit if you include Windsor), 1 city with a metro pop just over 1 million (Grand Rapids), and a bunch of smaller metros in the 100-400k range. Everything south of M-20 is essentially urban punctuated with corn fields (only slightly exaggerating).
__________________
SW Portland | NW Portland
Reply With Quote
     
     
  #220  
Old Posted Jun 22, 2019, 2:44 PM
Tuckerman Tuckerman is offline
Registered User
 
Join Date: Mar 2006
Location: Atlanta
Posts: 814
States with one dominant big city:
Alabama: Birmingham
Arizona: Phoenix
Colorado: Denver
Georgia: Atlanta
Louisiana: NO
Maryland: Baltimore
Massachusetts: Boston
Minnesota: Twin Cities
Michigan: Detroit
Oregon: Portland
New York: NYC
Washington: Seattle

States with 2 big cities domination debatable:
Tennessee
Oklahoma
Missouri
Pennsylvania

States with multiple big cities, domination debatable:
California
Florida
Ohio
Texas
Reply With Quote
     
     
This discussion thread continues

Use the page links to the lower-right to go to the next page for additional posts
 
 
Reply

Go Back   SkyscraperPage Forum > Discussion Forums > City Discussions
Forum Jump


Thread Tools
Display Modes

Forum Jump


All times are GMT. The time now is 4:12 PM.

     

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2019, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.