Quote:
Originally Posted by PBRSTREETGANG
Paragraph away: what's so ridiculous about repurposing Copps into a better used, shared facility instead of having it sit squat, idle, ugly, and aging for too much of the year?
He put out an idea in a public forum; he didn't say that his plan was perfect--this is how a community talks to itself. There's some merit to his ideas, and Ryerson's spearheading of MLG has worked out tremendously.
|
There is a difference between "not perfect" and "not at all thought out or reasoned." I will go with a few points instead of a few outright paragraphs:
- Trying to completely recreate something that has been an apparent success somewhere else does not guarantee success in Hamilton. The situation here feels far from "somewhat parallel" to that in Toronto.
- What would the goal of something like this be? The current arena is doing no harm as is, there is already lots of ground-floor retail space at the base of the arena in Jackson Square, including a full gym (GoodLife), a grocery store that is opening soon, and loads of empty space in JS and the City Centre in which you could place any other type of retail. There is also no historical preservation aspect as with Maple Leaf Gardens.
- I do not know much about architecture, but it feels like this would be an extremely difficult conversion project. Maple Leaf Gardens' exterior is a flat box, while at least part of Copps follows the contours of the upper deck seating, which would have to be pulled inward. A supermarket or whatever would have to be below ground.
- The Maple Leaf Gardens project cost $60 million. I do not see nearly as much appetite for spending anywhere near this amount for something like this at Copps. What was done in Toronto was done in a very built-up downtown, while there are still loads of large empty spaces in downtown Hamilton and chances to start fresh instead of retrofitting existing buildings. No company would offer $15 million or whatever for naming rights --- Copps Coliseum in Hamilton simply does not have any cachet compared to Maple Leaf Gardens in Toronto.
- Copps is not "woefully lacking in size and capacity for a modern-day [NHL] hockey". It is small in terms of luxury boxes, but those could conceivably be added.
- The thrown-out number of 5000 seats for the new arena is too small for the Hamilton Bulldogs. It feels like Larry has no idea how many seats Copps has, nor does he know how large NHL arenas are, nor does he know how large AHL arenas are.
- Even if the modified arena were to hold 9000 seats, it would do away with event opportunities that would repeat great big-name event experiences that Copps has brought to Hamilton in the past (U2, Bruce Springsteen, Britney Spears [three times], Lady Gaga [upcoming], Pavarotti [almost], NHL exhibition and regular-season games, NBA exhibition games). Copps Coliseum has contributed to giving Hamilton a big-city feel.
- The new Tiger-Cats stadium will probably be less than ideal for concerts, could only accommodate them in warm months, would very likely have poorer acoustics than Copps, and would bring back the same disruptions to the neighbourhood that had basically eliminated concerts at Ivor Wynne Stadium.
- This article is such a basic non-thought-out brain dump that I do not even buy it as the stated "beginning thoughts" and I would expect more of a former mayor of the city.