Some VERY interesting ideas here. And I really wish Smith would quit with the negative campaigning; it is making him look really bad and I think he is losing supporters (he is quickly losing me, that's for sure):
*And the museum is technically in Susquehanna Twp. WHAT?!? I worked there, and we paid local taxes to the city, had the city PD respond to incidents, etc. Maybe the City and the Twp. worked out some sort of an agreement?!? If so, this is news to me.
Challengers label Reed's museum as a lost cause
This is the first in a series of four stories on issues in the
Harrisburg mayor's race. Other stories -- on taxes, residential and commercial development, and education -- will appear each Monday.
Monday, April 18, 2005
BY JOHN LUCIEW
Of The Patriot-News
Harrisburg never saw fighting in the Civil War, but America's bloodiest war, more than 140 years ago, has become a factor in this year's race for mayor.
This time, the battle is over the city's National Civil War Museum and Mayor Stephen R. Reed's plan to create a critical mass of at least five city-owned museums to drive tourism in Harrisburg.
Reed's opponents -- former city policeman Ernie Napoli and design-firm owner Jason Smith -- have other ideas for the sprawling museum atop Reservoir Park.
Reed and his two challengers are vying for the Democratic nomination in the May 17 primary, and the Civil War's long shadow could play a role in the outcome.
Smith has suggested closing the museum, selling its artifacts and relocating City Hall and Harrisburg's police, fire and public safety offices -- now based downtown -- to the museum site.
Since he announced the idea in February, Smith said, it has become a centerpiece of his campaign.
"For many years, the people of Harrisburg have scratched their heads over the Civil War museum," Smith said. "My idea has caught on like wildfire. Everywhere I go, in every neighborhood, people tell me they like the concept."
Napoli also is in favor of shuttering the museum. But he'd like to see it become the clubhouse for a public golf course at the park, or even a casino. He said he'd also entertain offers to sell the building for a corporate headquarters.
"It's a beautiful building," Napoli said. "It's gorgeous, but it's not bringing in any money. It should be in Gettysburg."
When the museum opened in February 2001 at a cost of $39 million, including $17 million in artifacts, it was one of the proudest moments of Reed's 19 years in office. (Now in his sixth term, Reed has served 23 years as mayor.)
Then Sept. 11 terrorism struck, the economy crashed and the bottom fell out of the travel and tourism market.
Reed is blunt about the museum's struggles in its first several years. But he's also optimistic about its future, saying the operation is leaner and nearly breaking even. He predicts a better year in 2005.
While conceding that the museum is an "easy target," Reed rules out as "ridiculous" any suggestion of closing it.
For starters, Reed said, the moment the building is closed for another use, the city would be on the hook for $17 million that the state kicked in for the project.
Selling the artifacts isn't the answer, either, he said, because those purchases served as the city's match for the state funds.
Reed added that the building isn't big enough to house all city operations, meaning a City Hall switch would require a multimillion-dollar overhaul and expansion of the building. Moving costs, including rewiring the building for voice and electronic communications, could total nearly $3 million.
Beyond that, switching the building to a City Hall or a corporate headquarters would change the placid nature of Reservoir Park, Reed said.
"We're a 24/7 operation," he said of the city. "There would be traffic going in and out of there day and night."
But perhaps the major reason against change is that the museum is in Susquehanna Twp., Reed said.
"The prospect of moving the city government center to Susquehanna Twp. would not be in the city's interests," he said.
While split on the past, the candidates appear to be more in agreement about shaping Harrisburg's future as a tourist destination.
Smith rose to prominence by successfully fighting Reed's plan for a Wild West museum. He and Reed reached an agreement in February 2004 under which Reed would sell $500,000 of the $4.5 million in Western artifacts he'd acquired.
The money would go to fund a study that would guide the city's efforts at boosting tourism and creating attractions.
Smith played a lead role in refining the concept for a planned African-American Heritage Center in Harrisburg. Reed supported the concept, and it's now on the fast track to becoming the city's next museum.
However, Smith said he now disagrees with the museum's proposed midtown location, even though he selected it.
Reed said he would be bound by the $192,000 tourism study, which is under way by the National Trust for Historic Preservation.
But Reed has also acknowledged buying the occasional Civil War or African artifact, even after the storm of criticism over his millions of dollars in Wild West purchases, uncovered in July 2003.
These latest purchases were made the same way as Reed's Western artifact purchases. The nontax money came from funds held by the Harrisburg Authority, which earns fees for floating bonds and making other financial deals for municipalities.
However, Reed's most recent purchases have been in the tens of thousands of dollars, not millions, and they are for museums already built or well into the planning stages.
Even Smith said his agreement with the mayor involved halting purchases of only Western artifacts, not items for other museums.