Quote:
Originally Posted by SignalHillHiker
Well... I have only spent about two days, total, in Saint John in my life. And, honestly, I found it depressing. Compared to Moncton, it was depopulated, empty... and the fact it was so impressive, and so beautiful, only made the emptiness feel even more hurtful.
But... there are no words for the beauty of Saint John. The old part of the city, the downtown, which they call Uptown, is taller and more immaculate than either St. John's or Halifax. The heritage buildings in Saint John are 5-6 floors high. They're 4-5 in Halifax, and almost universally 3 in St. John's.
|
The uptown area (with the exception of the Fundy Quay area, when there's a cruise ship in town) does have that sort of depopulated rust belt feel, and the fact that the city was
clearly built to be a grand capital only makes it feel more unfortunate. The crumbling sidewalks and withered street trees, etc, don't help, nor does the fact that of New Brunswick's urban areas, it's the poorest, and all the middle-class and well-off people tend to have moved out of the city for the burbs (partially, frankly, because the weather in the old city can be miserable. In summer, it can be 20 degrees and foggy in town, and nearly 30 degrees and sunny just 20 minutes away in Quispamsis.) It's also got an older population compared to Fredericton and Moncton.
BUT: As you say, the bones of the city are astonishing, even if it is small. It probably has nearly as many great 19th-century buildings in Uptown as, say, Toronto has in total. I was completely unprepared the first time I saw it. I don't know what's up with the heritage regulations, but the buildings are mostly well-kept, too, right down to details like heritage-appropriate doors and window fittings, yet it still doesn't feel like a museum.
Here are some pics (which seem to feature a lot of closeups of lintels, but hey, those are nice.)
It's probably the Canadian city that's most ripe for an urban renaissance, and that's already happening, very slowly, as some new stuff opens up and there's been a slow creep of people back into Uptown, but at the current pace it's still a long ways off from feeling very vital and vibrant. I simply can't believe, however, that there won't, one day, be a resurgence. It just seems too fundamentally well-built to not come back at some point.
Quote:
Originally Posted by lio45
Really? I just had a look at ErickMontreal's superb Saint John photo thread and did not see anything in the same leagues as Montreal's late 1800s commercial stock.
|
It's not quite to that scale, but it's close, and the architectural quality is just as good.