I share DAC oppinion, shortly here my impressions:
A train station should be huge, wide, and receive the trains tracks for space to communters any direction, without conflicts. So the first is more for a good museum, i really do not see where trains movement goes, even when i do not like much this interaction of green grass on top of buildings, infiltration problems, humidity, spiders and so ever.. The second seems an attractive simple shaped glassy modern design, easy to implement, and feeling good inside and outside. Remember that any train station should have many taxi, Bus lines, and even subway and tram connections, parking garage. So this must be showed as well, which i see in the 2nd presentation, my vote.
________________________________________________________________________________________________________
About competition @Aleks, i've already sent yesterday a PM about your allowance and gentle oppinion in the way i do a competition for publically all talent guys all over the world who wants to participate. I understood i need to contact you first, before commenting that, but as you said about this thema, i wrote here. I hope compreheension. I've enough time to manage and answer properly the guys. Seems interesting, i would manage it, coordinate the doubts daily in a thread until all entries got for an end time of 3 months, time enough to respect the real people activities in real lifes, but stimulate the talent of everyone that they show further in their portfolio. Also i hope would be some new, totally different and maybe excited for getting attraction in participation. So please answer me. Thanks anyway. Of course i will not participate myself with an entry cause i do not have easy access and abbility at home to do a professional presentation rendered., but i can do only one at a time. A 2nd thread would be open since January 2010 for showing the results, 2 per member maximum with a maximum of 5 images showing the footprint plan as well. In first thread images should not be allowed, only doubts and the competion contest general requirements or directions. This is to avoid copies and in order to have more famous architects all over the world. I unfortunatly can not award properly people, but a poll would be enough for a general feeling. Hope everybody understand.....
Last edited by M.K.; Sep 17, 2009 at 6:18 PM.
|