Quote:
Originally Posted by Syndic
Again, migol24, you miss the point. I'm not saying it's a neighborhood right now. The point is that the buildings and streets will be there longer than the current retailers or owners. In fact, one day it will just be another (public) part of the city and buses will run on it all the time. What's important is the buildings. It wouldn't matter if the place were run by full-fledged Nazis. Austin benefits from the buildings they will leave behind when they're gone.
You see, a lot of people can't venture to think in the long-term like this, but I do. Whether the roads are private or public transportation goes there are small, fleeting issues. In the long term, it won't even be a question. The mixed-use buildings will remain, and they will be a legitimate part of our wider urban fabric.
I, for one, think simply building mixed-use and creating demand for mixed-use living has value, because it will lead to more being built and a change in the paradigm. Instead of developers building box stores and subdivisions of suburban houses, they'll be tempted/pressured to build mixed-use. And when/if the shit hits the fan and the economy collapses (again), high-end retailers will close up shop and move and hopefully more practical and useful tenants (like grocers) will move into that retail space.
Lots of you are looking for cool points in denouncing the Domain, but I still think that's a bit contrived and myopic. No one is saying that it's anything close to a second downtown, at all. No one.
|
What makes you think I'm not understanding you? I get what you're saying completely. What I'm saying is that for
now, what it is is not a neighborhood and only time will tell if it will or will not become a neighborhood and that we should also keep close tabs as a community by not letting this kind of development to continue by paving huge parking lots without any proper public transportation. What's gonna happen to the huge parking lots that surround this "future neighborhood"? If it becomes public domain in the future, how do you think we're gonna stop some corporate businesses to continue paving more parking lots, banning more public transportation and catering only to rich folks? You wanna wait another 30 years for that to happen, or until "shit hits the fence" again? This example is best illustrated in the Seaholm Power Plant. What was it, 50 years after we've decided to make use of it in an urban mixed way(not sure when its original use was abandoned)? Well we had that opportunity but voila, another project bites the dust to some corporation and what was hyped to be a "mixed use project" now will only serve for offices.
What I'm saying is this, what's with this attitude of "well maybe its not progress but at least it's something" attitude? Nah man, grow some balls of steel, gather as a community and protest that shit. At some point we gotta realize that one step forward, two steps back approach really isn't progress. Austin is growing really really fast and quite frankly there is no time for these types of developments to keep happening just so that we can wait for "shit to hit the fence" then we'll see some mom-and-pop shops starting to gear steam another 20 years from now. To me, quite frankly, that is not progress.
Ultimately, I respect your views, and I hope that it happens the way you predict. How long would it take for that to happen is the big question cause I'm getting a little tired of Texas developing another pseudo-urban development and everyone praising it as progress. I don't understand that mentality, but who knows maybe it will work eventually. I've just yet to see a true urban landscape anywhere in Texas and that's where "shit really hits the fence".
And also... just to make things clear. I've said this before that I'm actually not quite as passionately against the Domain, per se. I enjoyed going there, well because it looks a little cool to me and I liked going to the Apple store there and it definitely beat going to Barton Creek Mall. I'm just calling it as it is. The Domain ain't really "progress". And as for people's denouncing of the project. It's completely warranted to an extent if you ask me. Unless you really really really like shopping malls that much.