Quote:
Originally Posted by pilsenarch
River North, North Michigan Ave., Wabash, State, Streeterville, there are endless examples of neighborhoods with both tall towers and walkable streets with active retail/restaurant uses in just this city alone.
|
He's got a valid point, although I'm not sure it's universally true that skyscrapers create an uncomfortable environment.
River North only has sporadic skyscrapers. North Michigan Avenue is a mid-rise scaled street, again with sporadic skyscrapers. Wabash is lined with buildings that are mid-rises by a modern definition (apart from the Heritage/Legacy combo and CNA). State also has few skyscrapers - only Citadel Center and Unitrin/Renaissance. Streeterville is chock-full of skyscrapers, and it has a crappy pedestrian environment, except along St. Clair, which still has lots of small older buildings.
I think it is true that a neighborhood composed exclusively of large-lot skyscrapers doesn't have the fine grain of a pedestrian-friendly neighborhood. In Chicago, this includes Lakeshore East, Central Station, Streeterville, and several corridors in the Loop.
In the opposite direction, it mystifies me that Clark St in Lincoln Park is such a magnet. IMO the scale is too low - most of the buildings are only one story.