Quote:
Originally Posted by Mike K.
You can still make general update threads and turn them into mega-threads if you like, but if there's an on-going discussion in a mega-thread about a topic or project then turn it into a separate thread. That's really the only "rule," and even that is a lose rule by most standards.
For the regulars who check everyday mega-threads don't present issues but for those who want to join in on conversations and don't follow discussions every day, or for newbs, it's extremely difficult to jump in. I see newbs asking questions that may have been answered on page 33 of a 50-page mega-thread but they don't know that so the regulars shun them or don't even care to answer. Some say "do a search" and carry on with asides. This sort of thing not only alienates new users and non-regulars but it keeps them from participating. This is unfortunately a side-effect of mega-threads thus creating separate threads where individuals can easily follow the flow of discussion and find relevant info quickly really is a respectful and much more engaging format. We don't want forums to become old boys clubs, but sometimes that is invariably what happens.
Since we've only been live with this sub-forum for a few days is it really too much to ask to just give it a try for a little while longer? We're trying to bring some change here to attract more people to participate and it would be nice to have some of the regulars help us do it. If it's a failure in a few months, we'll deal with it then. But until then this place really is what you make it, nothing more, nothing less.
|
You may be making assumptions about who is "new" and who is not. I am the one being critical, and I am the relatively new user you appear to be seeking.
I understand the reasons for attempting this swtichover as they have been stated.
However, I got the hang of your old format just fine. Others would too.
Cheers.
-BrG
Prev
Linear Mode
