Quote:
Originally Posted by AylmerOptimist
That is what people get wrong. That is what they don't get.
High buildings doesn't take away any of the "humaness" but, if anything, adds to it;
What is humaness? is it small buildings? because I can tell you this, Barhaven isn't human by any stretch of the imagination. The humaness of which you reffer is attributed by the humans. Hence the word HUMANess. Even the ones that live in EXTREMELY high, unhuman residences. So next time you walk around looking sourly at the, ummm, "high" buildings, try to imagine if all of them lived in Orleans: the market would be a couple thousand humans less human!
|
When I say this building is too tall, I'm certainly not advocating the construction of suburban-style single-family homes in the Market area! As we all know, to have a vibrant (and safe) community, you need high density, a lively streetscape with a good mix of street-level retail services, and a pedestrian friendly environment (ie., trees, wide sidewalks, sunlight, etc). The question is how best to achieve it? The CBD has none of these qualities, which is why Sparks Street is doomed to remain in its current sad state. Suburban high-rise developments may achieve high density but typically lack the other two requirements. What does work in an area like the Market is a series of low-rise (3 to 4 storey) apartment blocks sitting atop street-level retail. This creates the density needed without the inherent drawbacks of towering high-rises.
90 George Street is a perfect example of willy-nilly development that sets a bad precedent for the Market's southern boundary. (Really, who wants to be sipping a cocktail at a patio with apartments towering high above you?) Besides, like the other writer here said, with its boxy utilitarian design, it is kinda ugly. Can you see a tourist visiting the Market point to it and say "Wow, look at
that, kids"? (I can't.)
I have nothing against tall towers (why else would I be here?). But they have their place, and it's certainly not in a historic district like the Byward Market. Just take a walk in practically any European city to see how it should be done.