Quote:
Originally Posted by nashvol85
It is a neat building and definitely worthy of saving -- but let's not get carried away.
|
Not getting carried away at all, its how I see things. Some of our great modernist buildings of today are under threat just like our older architecture was during urban renewal. Just like planners in the urban renewal era took for granted the architecture of the past they were trying to destroy, planners of today don't appreciate modernist architecture and the masterful simplicity these buildings represent. These mistakes often do repeat themselves, and instead of renovating and repurposing we're opting to destroy buildings that have a shelf life of hundreds of years. There are modernist structures being demolished all over the place. These steel and concrete buildings can arguably last longer than any type of construction in history if they are maintained, renovated, and repurposed as needed. They're much stronger and more durable than any of the brick and mortar buildings so many people adore from the more distant past. I'm not saying they don't need major renovations and groundwork changes. A lot of modernist buildings need a complete rebuild of the lobbies and plazas to connect them to the environment as many were put on top of ugly parking garages or slabs of concrete facing the street with no connection. Yet, I'd opt for repurposing and reconstruction rather than demolition and replacement.
For example, the UPBank tower in Memphis is (I think) vacant. Its a beautiful example from this era as well. It needs to be cared for, rebuilt, repurposed. They could lop off the top of the building and replace the space ship with something more modern, but tear it down? I'd hate to see that day come. It would be a terrible loss for the city.
Re: Tunica, I think the entire Tunica experiment was built way too far outside of the Memphis proper area and its just out of place in so many ways. The new I-69 connections may make it easily accessible, but its still a remote handful of casinos in the middle of farmland with nothing connected to it for many miles around.
But its already done, the casinos are there, and the highways have been built. It does need to be marketed as a regional attraction and integrated with the Memphis market. While it is a bit displaced, its still part of the Memphis market.