St Patrick's Island bridge comp: Which one do you like?

[earthclaim]

Interesting, before seeing any of the results I figured I would favour a cable stayed or suspension type bridge and yet none of the proposals of that type would be my choice - my top five currently being in no particular order (since I haven't decided on an order yet) the two Halcrow Yolles', Marc Boutin's, and the two SPFa's. Arup/Kasian and Sturgess then are a close six and seven.

I do like the concepts in the Saucier and Perrotte design but a) am not sure of the practicality for the location and b) the tube shape is too much like the peace bridge. I think it would be great for a long +15 though where security around the dark ends would not be an issue.