Quote:
Originally Posted by pseudolus
I would come to the exact opposite conclusion: that these extensions to the hinterlands are cannibalizing existing riders and not adding new riders and are therefore a great squandering of scarce transit dollars.
|
Since when are Fremont and San Jose "the hinterlands"?
Anyway, before Warm Springs station was built, the Fremont station had roughly the same amount of riders as Fruitvale and Macarthur stations in Oakland, Daly City Station, and more riders than Ashby or North Berkeley (which it still does), or Glen Park station in SF. And at the reduced numbers it still sees about as many riders as Lake Merritt and Coliseum in Oakland, West Oakland, and the SFO station too. Seems like plenty of people are using it, by BART standards.
As for Warm Springs station, it has a pretty normal level of usage for a suburban BART station, similar to Concord, Castro Valley, and Orinda. Give it time, as there there are plans for development around Warm Springs station, so ridership should rise a little (having access to SJ should eventually attract more riders too). I doubt it'll ever be that busy of a station, but it is still comparable in ridership to multiple existing stops. And it is worth noting that Fremont in total has 800 more riders per day now than it did last year, which is a larger increase than from 2014-2015 and 2015-2016.
As for the future stations in San Jose, I'm sure Berryessa will see at least as many riders as the Fremont stations. And I'm guessing the downtown San Jose station would see even more daily riders....I'm thinking maybe 10,000-15,000, which would put it close to Downtown Oakland, Downtown Berkeley, and the SF mission district stations. But even if it only saw, say, 7-9,000 riders, it would still be comparable to stations within SF, Berkeley, and Oakland.
check the stats:
https://www.bart.gov/about/reports/profile