Quote:
Originally Posted by 65MAX
Ummm, this kind. The OMB's ranking of Metropolitan Areas by population. Portland is NOT 2.3 million, as you claim. It's 3 million and growing.
So not only is it larger than Pittsburgh (2.66 million), Baltimore (2.75 million) and St. Louis (2.9 million), but it's also larger than Tampa (not 4 million, but 2.85 million)
And yet all four of those cities have both MLB and NFL teams. As do Kansas City and Cincinnati (2.38 and 2.19 million respectively). And that's not even including other smaller cities that have just an NFL or MLB team (i.e. Charlotte, Indianapolis, Milwaukee, Nashville, Jacksonville, New Orleans, Buffalo and Green Bay). So that's a total of 14 other SMALLER cities that are supporting MLB and/or NFL teams.
A new stadium is a big hurdle for ANY city, not just Portland. That's the only legitimate obstacle to getting an NFL or MLB team here. All of the population arguments are just plain ridiculous.
|
I'm from Buffalo, so I'll refer to your list from a Buffalo point of view.
First of all, it separates Buffalo and Rochester, which is like separating San Diego from Tijuana or Orange County for figuring out regional draws. It also leaves out Syracuse, and there are a lot of Syracuse area Bills fans. It also leaves out Jamestown, which is basically Buffalo's Salem. On that list those are all counted as separate metro areas from Buffalo, even though they're all within a reasonable day trip from Ralph Wilson Stadium.
It also leaves out Niagara Falls, Hamilton, Fort Erie, Toronto, and lots of other Canadian cities that are nearby.
Portland is one of the big west coast cities, but it's also relatively isolated.
San Diego/LA teams draw from the entire Southern California Area (including parts of LA, SD, Riverside, and Orange Counties). Bay Area teams get the cities of San Francisco, Oakland, San Jose, and their suburbs to watch. Seattle teams get pretty much most of WA and a good percentage of OR.
Also there are ownership rules that would prevent an NFL team here unless Paul Allen divested himself of either the Seahawks or the Blazers.
MLB might be an option, I don't know their ownership rules as well, but it seems absurd to think Portland will get a team that's any league other than CFL or NHL. MLB TV local TV rights matter more and those aren't going to be a goldmine in Oregon.
The really important thing (other than being a more remote market) is that the NFL is pretty strict about ownership rules.
Edited to add, I went with these numbers which also have flaws.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Portlan...atistical_area