I have no comment at all for this design. It just like shopping mail.
But the idea of planting trees is good!
I dont think the buildings look like CCTV tower in Beijing.. But, i do think it is very similar to La Grande Arche in Paris.
At the beginning, i think that this design is the best one But after watching the video and the pics, i think that this design does not intergrate into the environment and the LegCo building does not suit the style of the main building. (While other buildings in the poposal are designed based on boxes, the LegCo building has round structure.)
Moreover, I think that the green area of A is good, but i start to think that grass platfrom may not be accepted for Hongkongers and there are no trees!
I believe that noone will sit on this platform under sun exposeure and 3X degree. But, the idea of connection from Queensway to the seaside is great.
After rejecting A for the best one, i started thinking of D.
For D, the circular-seaside-footbridge is amazing for me, but, it may not be a part of the contract.
For myself, the building is quite special and acceptable.
The theme is clear and observable, although it seems like a casino.
But after looking at the video, i find out that the buildings are too high that the Far East Finace Centre and other buildings in Queensway will be hided from the point of view of tsimshatsui.
So, i stopped thinking of D.
At first, i think that the designer of C is just crazy.
But after rejecting all other designs, i start take a look on C.
I found that the green area is quite a large proportion of tamar site and there are trees, although i do not like the design as it is as usual as other places in HK.
Looking at the design, I found that none of the buildings in Queensway will be hided by the design and it is highly intergrated into the background when people looking from Tsimshatsui. And, from central, people can enjoy another unforgettable view from the horizontal side of the building.
However, i think that the office of CE is a bit strange from the whole design.
So, to conclude, I think the perfect design should have C's main buildings, D's seaside-footbridge, A's green area connection, and B's planting trees idea!